Storm Follow-up

The last storm was Friday almost exactly a week ago, but this time I think everyone was prepared. We had our buckets in the attic under the leaks, all the potted plants were safely inside and the windows shut against the wind and rain. After the storm, with no further rain in the forecast, everybody was ready to move on and forget it all. But curious about the cumulative rainfall, I did want to give a recap of the storms and their effects.

Last Friday’s storm felt like the worst. It was the 4th in a row, and as I mentioned, everyone was talking about it and preparing for it. Once we were ready, I went to bed thinking the rain wasn’t so bad. But even though I slept through the night, my wife said the rain came down in solid sheets, waking her up and drawing her outside to watch. This last storm was the most intense, with huge amounts of rain in a short time, creating lots of runoff. In the morning, I found my thick, heavy rubber doormat swept down the walkway from my door—so the runoff from the street must’ve been deep and strong.

There were again reports of some serious weather:

  • A friend in Kapahi reported macademia-nut sized hail, which was later confirmed by a photo in the newspaper.
  • The Kealia stream rose so much, it covered Haua’ala Road in the Keapana valley area just north of Kapa’a. Because it’s the only road into the valley, residents were trapped until the river went down.
  • The newspaper also reported another funnel cloud that apparently touched down near Lihu’e. It did rip some shingles off a roof, and led to the best quote in a long time:
  • The small twister left the Steins’ children’s toys strewn about the neighborhood “much more than they normally are,” her husband chided.

  • There was a report of water flowing over the main Wailua bridge, leading the police to close the bridge, just as in Hanalei.
    WailuaBridgeClosureFBPost
    At first I thought this meant the river rose so much it covered the bridge. But then I had a look at the bridge, and I won’t say it’s impossible, but for the river to go that high, it would have to flood the marina and Kuamo’o road nearby, not to mention a few houses and businesses by the river. Since I saw no evidence of this, I think what happened is that runoff from the hill and road nearby washed onto the bridge and couldn’t drain fast enough, creating water on the bridge.
  • Finally, someone heard from someone that there was snow in Koke’e.
    KokeeSnowFBComment
    Given the hail, it seems plausible at least. I asked for more information (pics, or it didn’t happen), but I haven’t heard any further details. What seems more likely is that it hailed in Koke’e as well. So I’m still looking for first-hand witnesses and/or photographic evidence of snow on Kaua’i.

Everyone was saying how this last storm was the worst of the 4, and even worse than the “30 days of rain” back in 2006. It certainly seemed like there was more rain and more runoff in a shorter period this time. But looking at the rain gauge totals for the past 21 days, the 2nd and 3rd storms (March 4th and 5th-6th), were generally the wettest in most areas. I think the difference was the general saturation of the ground, meaning that the 4th storm created more impressive runoff everywhere.

In order to add up the rain gauge totals, I downloaded all the data from the National Weather Service and created a spreadsheet (click to download) and some graphs. This first graph (click to see the full frame) shows the cumulative rain every 12 hours for each gauge that had data the whole period:

Rain21DaySeries

What still impresses me about the first storm is how it was so uniformly significant over the entire island. In my experience observing the rain gauge maps, that is very unusual. Typically, some areas receive more and others less, such as how the Westside stayed dry through the rest of these storms. You can see other trends, such as how Hanalei and Wainiha (the North Shore) dwarfed Wai’ale’ale at times, but how a minor rain on Feb 29 really affected the summit. However, this second graph shows the 21-day cumulative total for each of the gauges, and Wai’ale’ale still dominates:

Rain21DayTotals

After all the rain, my daughter was anxious to get outside and play. Unfortunately, the main part of Lydgate Park is still closed. The roads are open, but the beach is washed out and pools are full of silt (as I reported earlier). On top of that, there was a sewage spill around the Kamalani playground, so it is closed and roped off. The good news is that the play-bridge structure at the south end of the park is open:

LydgateSouthPlayBridge

The dirt road that goes under the bridge and out to the beach has turned back into a stream. This was a natural channel I believe, and with all the runoff from the golf course nearby, it connects to the ocean again for now.

LydgateSouthWater

The water in the ocean is still brown, so there is no swimming on the east side for another week or so. The beach is covered in drift wood as well:

LydgateSouthDriftwood

The newspaper had a photo of runoff damange at Ke’e beach that caused a deep gully in the sand. The same thing happened at the picnic area at the south end of Lydgate park as well. This channel is 4-6 feet deep and the flow washed sand from under the boulder, causing it to sink about 4 feet:

LydgateSouthErosion

This is what happens when you build roads and parking lots without proper drainage near the beach. In heavy rain, they turn into an artificial stream that takes the shortest path to the beach (the human path), and it carries all the sand along with it.

But the worst damage from this last storm is in Kapa’ia, the little valley between Hanamaulu and Lihu’e. You can see how the stream banks were scoured by the high flow, and a week after the storm the stream is still about twice as wide as usual:

HanamauluStreamFlood

The flash flood in this valley carried lots of branches and uprooted trees, and unfortunately, smashed them into the Kapa’ia swinging bridge:

KapaiaSwingingBridgeBroken

This is sad because the local community was trying to raise awareness and money to get this bridge restored. The wood was rotting, and they had to close the bridge because it was unsafe. I don’t know exactly what it needed, but now I wonder if it can be saved at all. It is one of the 4 swinging bridges on Kaua’i, a relic of an older time. If the cables are still sound, maybe this will encourage the restauration of the bridge.

Not all is gloomy, this lotus flower (at the Coconut Marketplace) looked even nicer with some raindrops:

LotusRainDrops

And my neighbor sent me a great photo of the waterfall on Nounou, the Sleeping Giant, although it was actually from the previous Monday’s storm. So here’s a 300 foot (100 meter) waterfall you don’t see everyday:

NounouWaterfall20120305

Because the east side still has plenty of brown water, there will be no swimming in the ocean for a few more days.

I heard Poipu was sunny early this week when the east side was still overcast, so I took my daughter down there to swim. Sure enough, it was warm and the water safe to swim, so she had a good time at Poipu Beach Park. And we got to see a sunset for the first time in a long time:

PoipuBeachSunshine

PoipuSunset20120312

The weather island-wide is now definitely turning into spring, with warm sunshine, breezes, and clean fresh air. With all the water and now sunshine, the land is lush and green again. Not having seen the direct sun in so long, I am surprised by how far north it has moved in the sky. Following a typical pattern, these storms are now hitting California, which will soon be all green as well. Just in time for St. Patrick’s Day.

Kalalau for Beginners

I’ve mentioned this before: feel free to send me questions, my email is andy (a) great(dash)hikes (d o t) c o m. It used to be on this website, but I had to take it down due to spam. Eventually, I would like to implement an “Ask me about Kaua’i” button, but email works in the meantime. I try to answer all emails, and if it has a wide appeal, I’ll just publish the answer here.

Janis sent me a question, and I think the answer may interest a lot of people:

My husband and I just returned from a trip to Kauai and we just loved everything about it. We hiked the trail to Hanakapai Falls and are contemplating trying the whole 11 miles to Kalalau Beach. We are in our upper 50′s, in relatively good shape, but have never backpacked before. Would you only recommend this trail for young people?

Also, what is the best way to overcome a possible fear of exposure on the cliff sections? I think I could possibly have a problem, but I really want to overcome my fear and do this hike. It is now on my bucket list.

Any suggestions other than “don’t do it”? ha.

Janis, I think backpacking in general is not a question of age but of experience. I helped my Dad hike the Kalalau trail when he was 65, and there are plenty of people of all ages hiking in Kalalau. In fact, given that experience comes with age, you see lots of old backpackers on trails all over the country. However, by your own admission, I’m not sure you have all the experience to tackle the Kalalau trail yet. It sounds like you have a good fitness level, so I think with some equipment and training, you could do it in a year or two. There is also the issue of sleeping outdoors in a tent or hammock—some people have no problem with it, others will put up with it to be in Kalalau, and yet others just aren’t comfortable with it. Since you’ve already considered this, I’m going to assume you’re not in the last category.

Having never backpacked before, you need some equipment and skills. Hopefully there is a hiking club near where you live that you can join and learn about backpacking skills. Sometimes you can rent or borrow their equipment first, until you buy your own. For Kalalau, you will need to bring the following with you on the airplane:

  • Backpacks
  • Hiking boots and hiking poles (recommended when you have a heavy pack on your back)
  • Shelter (usually a lightweight backpacking tent, but could also be a hammock with rain fly for each)
  • Mats for insulation from the ground (if in tent)
  • Lightweight sleep sack (you don’t need the heavier sleeping bag that’s necessary the mainland, so unless you can afford a down bag, a separate fleece sleep sack is lighter and smaller to pack).
  • Water filter and purifier rated to remove leptospira bacteria
  • Camping food
  • Lightweight hiking clothes (breathable synthetic fabrics)
  • Kalalau map (though it is easier to buy on Kaua’i, see links below)

None of this needs to be expensive, but you should have good quality equipment that fits well and that you’ve practiced packing, carrying, and using. Some of it can be rented on Kaua’i at the backpacking stores, but I really think that bringing an extra suitcase or pack as luggages is a small price to pay for having your own trusted equipment with you.

I no longer recommend taking a stove to Kalalau because it can be a hassle to take on the airplane. They all have different rules about them. Since you’re usually going for 3-4 days, it’s not an ordeal to eat cold foods. If you do want hot foods and are willing to deal with the extra weight, you need to determine if you can take it on your airline (before you buy tickets) and under what conditions, and then buy the gas on Kaua’i.

Once you have borrowed, rented, or bought this equipment, you need practice carrying it long distances and using it. The Kalalau trail has over 2500 feet of elevation gain over 11 miles. You don’t want this unfamiliar trail in an unfamiliar climate to be a surprise and a huge challenge to your abilities. Because you say you’ve never been backpacking, you need to start light and go for a short distance for a single night. Practice setting up camp and making your water and food. As I mentioned, you should find a club or friends who backpack to help you learn about preparing, packing, hiking and camping safely. A lot of other skills such as route-finding (or just following the trail), weather prediction, staying warm, knowing first aid, and just staying safe in general are the same as with day-hiking, though usually require a bit more thought and effort in order to extend over the several days of a typical back-packing trip.

Then work your way up to 10 mile hikes with 30-lb packs. For Kalalau, you can stop at the 6-mile marker, but I actually don’t recommend it because it is a wet and muddy spot. It is much better to go lighter and faster (and longer) all the way to Kalalau (or even to a trail-side stop if you don’t make it all the way). The one difference I have found between backpacking in Hawaii and the mountains of California is the humidity. You must be prepared to drink more, stay cool, and avoid over-exertion. If you come from the eastern or southern states, you may be more prepared for the humid weather.

The fear of heights (acrophobia) is going to be an issue you should consider before you make all this investment in time and equipment. I don’t know if it can be overcome, but perhaps with experience and habit, you can manage it. So before you do the backpacking training, you may want to do “height training.” Find trails that require you to be near cliff edges, and see how you can deal with it. Take the hiking poles to give you more confidence. Start taking a larger pack on these cliff hikes to get a feel for the weight and balance near the edge. Not having such fears myself, I may be way off base here, but there may be mind-calming techniques such as meditation or affirmations you could look into. Nor do I don’t know if traditional psychologists can help, if you feel it is really blocking you.

The Kalalau trail does have some areas that I imagine will trigger a response in people who have fear of heights to some degree. The worst is the cliff section at about 6.5 miles where there is a passage on a narrow dirt trail, and then a rock balcony with a real drop-off. Other sections of the trail aren’t so bad, but there are erosion and overgrowth right next to steep and long slopes that go very far down to the ocean. It is all generally safe (but always exercise your own judgment based on actual trail conditions), but you might not be able to predict your fear-reaction, so the best you can do is to prepare yourself in similar situations.

Here are the most relevant articles I’ve posted, to cover some of what I mention above:

There are now tons of videos of the Kalalau trail on YouTube. Some people may not want to watch too much and keep the surprise and awe for their own hike. But you might want to watch the ones about the cliff section to see if you think you can handle the heights there (but of course, it is totally different in person without the distorting effect of the camera lens).

Finally, if you feel all this preparation and training might keep you from backpacking to Kalalau, another option would be to hire a guide. A competent guide can essentially give you the training you need, right on the trail. The guide should be able to provide most of the equipment, and then probably carry most of it so you only need a full day-pack instead of a backpack. You still need to be able to do 2 long and difficult 11-mile full-day hikes, deal with the humidity, and overcome your fear of heights. And it is probably expensive, but it may be a good way for you to “do” Kalalau, and you’d also be learning backpacking skills that would help you go other places on your own. For guided hikes, I always recommend Eric at Hike Kaua’i With Me (he has a facebook page too).

Best of luck, Janis, whatever you decide. Backpacking is a great way to explore the natural beauty of Kaua’i, the mainland, and all over the world. It might also be an activity that helps you conquer your fear of heights. Feel free to ask additional questions, and let me know when you get to Kalalau.

Storm Aftermath

Monday’s storm was really intense, but as the previous week, the normal weather came back fairly quickly. By Tuesday, there was hardly any rain on the coast, Wednesday and Thursday being almost sunny. It did rain more inland, and this created more run-off, but nothing like Monday’s fury.

First, some YouTube videos that are finally getting uploaded after the storm, starting with Opaeka’a falls and some other very temporary waterfalls:

You know, I did go looking for the waterfalls I had once seen on Nounou, but there were always too many clouds in the way.

Then there are the kids that found a wet hill to surf on. East-side residents can probably guess where this is:

And finally, what it was like to drive in the rain. I’ve seen more than one video where the driver is filming, but we’ll assume they were driving slowly to begin with.

That last one is rather telling, because the main damage from the storm was the closure of the Kapa’a Bypass due to a large culvert being eroded and undermining the roadway (photo at The Garden Island)–I wonder how many people drove over it in that condition. The state is working quickly to repair the culvert (HDOT has a release with photos) and reopen the road by next week.

KapaaBypassClosed

In the meantime, the closure is causing bad traffic on the main road, because inland Kapa’a traffic to the Kawaihau and Kapahi neighborhoods (half the Kapa’a population) is stuck on the main road. Count on at least an extra 20-30 minutes to get through Kapa’a, both northbound and southbound at rush hour. At least in Hawaii, you get rainbows with your traffic jams:

KapaaTrafficRainbow

There is another road closure on the main highway in Kilauea, again caused by a culvert eroding. That one took out half of the roadway, but they have a small detour in place and less traffic.

I did get out for the farmer’s market, and took Kamalu road behind the Sleeping Giant to avoid the traffic. I could tell I wasn’t the only person on the back roads. Do watch out for muddy spots where water washed some dirt over the road.


OlohenaRoadPotholes Another effect of the storm were all the pot holes in the roads from the extensive runoff. Once the water gets in a crack in the pavement, it washes away the dirt and digs a hole underneath.

Since I was out and about, I got some photos of the storm aftermath. Water was still flooding the side-streets down by the Coconut marketplace on Wednesday, but by today, there were only little lakes in the low-lying grass:

AlekaLoopFlooded

MarketPlacePond1

MarketPlacePond2

On the road to Lihue, the low lying areas around the county jail were flooded, including their vegetable gardens and outside exercise yard. You can see the drainage ditch in the forground overflowing.

CountyJailFlooding1
CountyJailFlooding2

On Kuamo’o Road, I stopped to see Opaeka’a falls again. The flow was somewhat diminshed, and the water no longer so brown, but the things to notice in this picture are the trees in between the two flows that were washed over and hanging on by their roots.

OpaekaaFallsAgain

Driving up Olohena Road, we were treated to this nice waterfall. Most of the water from this little stream is diverted into an irrigation ditch, so it’s usually just a trickle. And this area wasn’t even visible until they cleared out all the hau bush a few years ago.

OlohenaRoadWaterfall

And here’s the irrigation ditch diversion just upstream. Like all the little streams in the area, the vegetation got scoured and the mud banks were eroded one or two feet higher than the normal flow.

OlohenaRoadIrrigation

I went all the way up to the arboratum, but of course the truck in the water had already been removed. Flow was still high, almost as deep as a tire, which is still probably enough to push a car off the crossing. Heed the signs, people:

ArboratumCrossing1
ArboratumCrossing2

Another consequence of the flood seems to be the stream gauge further inland on the other branch of the Wailua river. It stopped recording even before Monday’s huge peak, and the graph shows a malfunction indicator. I guess we’ll never really know the actual height of the water, unless somebody goes to read it off the markings on the trees.

WailuaGaugeBroken
Source: USGS stream gauge data


On my way back down, it was getting dark, but I noticed that the Coco Palms lagoons were overflowing and flooding the entire grounds. They do have a sluice gate to let out more water, but I suppose that would then flood the other buildings by the river, ones that are actually being used (thrift store, kayak rentals, and canoe club). Better to let the unoccupied buildings be flooded. CocoPalmsFlooded1
CocoPalmsFlooded2 I think you can see the canoe docks under water at the top of this image.

Finally, I wanted to check on the rock pools at Lydgate. They were not as full of large debris as I imagined, because it looks like the storm swell overflowed the pools on the south side by the beach and carried away some of the branches.


However, both large and small pools were full of dark silt and the beaches partly covered in black mulch. LydgatePools1
LydgatePools2 Another effect of the storm was that the beach itself was eroded from the runoff. I think some of the sand at the Lydgate pools is man-made, or at least replenished by truck, and a lot of it washed down into the water, leaving gullies in the underlying dirt.

Overall, the damage in the aftermath of the storm was minor. Some roads are being repaired, some people in Hanalei have real flood damage, and I do have some leaks in my roof to deal with. But for the size of the storm and amount of water that flowed, it seems like it could’ve been much worse. I expected to hear people talking about how they made it through, but instead most of the people I overheard were talking about the next storm already, due on Friday. We shall see.

Rainy Day Redux

After a wet, wet, wet weekend, Monday was not all sunny like last week. In fact, it was quite the opposite. The rain came down by the bucketful today, barely letting up between torrential downpours. In the afternoon, the wind picked up and whipped the rain sideways across the lanai and into any open window on that side.

The rain totals for the day were impressive, with Hanalei getting 17.5 inches, and 6 gauges on Kaua’i over 10 inches within 24 hours:

RainyDayRedux
Source: NOAA/National Weather Service

I estimate we got between 8 and 10 inches in the Wailua Houselots. The yard was full of puddles again:

RainyDay2Yard

And now the roads in the neiborhood were starting to form pools:

RainyDay2Roads

And then around noon today, I heard the sound that every homeowner dreads: drip, drip, drip. I quickly climbed up in the attic and found 4 small leaks in the roof. I think the wind was lifting the shingles and blowing the rain underneath. I managed to crawl around the ceiling joists and put buckets under the leaks, before they soaked through the ceiling. The worst leak was at one of the holes for the solar hot water pipes going through the roof to the panels.

But as upsetting as that was, many people on Kaua’i have it worse. Koloa and Hanalei were flooded already yesterday, as shown on these news reports from last night:

And here is the Hanalei valley from today:

As you can see in that last one, the Hanalei river valley was flooded again as it was in November 2009. There are some houses and businesses along the river that probably have several feet of water inside. Since the road runs near the river, the water covered the road as well. I read they took people who needed to get out in heavy trucks. There were other road closures in places where streams and runoff covered the road. There was one lane closed at Kalihiwai Bridge which probably means it was flooded like November 2009 as well:

Update: it turns out it was a landslide that closed a lane at Kalihiwai Bridge (from an article in The Garden Island). There were also several road closures due to flooding and fallen trees, and the Kaua’i Beach Resort (formerly Hilton and Radisson) was without power and sent guests to the Lihue neighborhood center. The latest article from the Garden Island has a long list of incidents and closures, including a sewage spill at Lydgate.

I do have to say that we had electricity and internet connection all day, not even a flicker. We took advantage of that by snuggling in bed and watching a streaming movie tonight. So a big thanks to the utilities who built a tough network, and were probably out in this weather dealing with incidents.

The most impressive accident I saw reported so far was a pickup truck swept off of the river crossing at the Keahua Arboratum inland of Wailua. I wonder if the guy was stuck on the other side and desperate to get out, or show-boating (to use a nautical term):

That comes from an article titled “Flood warning extended for Kauai until 2:30 a.m.” and it is still raining off and on tonight, so stay safe out there. I’m just glad I used big buckets up in the attic.


Just for comparison, many towns on Kaua’i easily beat New York City’s record of 7.7 inches (set just last summer). But the rainiest day ever recorded on Kaua’i was back in 1956, according to the Western Regional Climate Center:

… during the storm of January 24-25, 1956, over 38 inches of rain fell at the Plantation Office, Kilauea Sugar Plantation, Kauai, within a 24-hour period, out of a storm total of 43.5 inches. During the same storm six inches of rain fell during a single 30-minute period and about 12 inches fell in one hour. The 38-inch value for 24 hours is conservatively low, because the gage was already overflowing when it was emptied for the first time. The six-inch value is correct within one or two tenths of an inch; the 12-inch value for one hour is an estimate only – again because of overflow – and may be in error by as much as an inch.

And records for the US are hard to find, but apparently, the record for 24-hour precipiation is Alvin, Texas with over 43 inches in 24 hours on July 25-26, 1979, due to tropical storm Claudette. For shorter periods, “a world record rainfall occurred at Holt, Missouri on June 22, 1947 when it rained 12 inches in just 42 minutes. This averages to over 1/4 of an inch of rainfall per minute. On July 4th, 1956 In Unionville, Maryland 1.23 inches of rain fell in 1 minute.”


Update: Someone caught the funnel cloud on video the other day and uploaded it to YouTube—the internet is a wonderful tool. The video shows it was over the water and actually tounched the ocean, creating a waterspout:

Funnel Cloud on Kaua’i

The strange weather continues: after a week of rain off and on, my wife spotted this small funnel cloud over Wailua on Saturday morning (March 3) around sunrise (7am):

FunnelCloud20120303_070233

She didn’t even bother to wake me up, so these are all her photos.

FunnelCloud20120303_070250

After about 30 seconds, it seemed to dissipate (hover over the photos to see the timestamps in each filename):

FunnelCloud20120303_070305

About a minute and a half later, it was strong enough to be visible again:

FunnelCloud20120303_070442

With the backlight from the sunrise, you could see the hollow tube shape:

FunnelCloud20120303_070509

Here is a closeup of the funnel cloud, at its thickest:

FunnelCloud20120303_070531

As it weakened again, it lost its shape:

FunnelCloud20120303_070613

About 3 minutes later, it finally dissipated, just as the rising sun found a hole in the clouds. You can still see the very thin and faint shape of it to the center-right of the image:

FunnelCloud20120303_070744

I did some searching on the internet, and funnel clouds are fairly unusual in Hawaii. I remember reading about one on Oahu during the storms in May last year–here are some photos of a double waterspout and a video. And there was another one in September that was nicely lit at sunset. However, funnel clouds, waterspouts, and tornadoes are not rare or unheard of: this research paper (PDF) reports 31 sightings between 1949 and 1960. And they do touch down and cause damage and injuries, the worst being 4 injuries and several million dollars of damage in Kailua-Kona (Big Island) in 1971.

The odd thing is that this happened the day after deadly tornadoes and storms hit the midwest United States, so we had storms and tornadoes on our minds. While we were fortunate to be spared such extreme weather, it was another rainy weekend with over 13 inches (330 mm) in one day at Hanalei (the bridge was closed again), and 17 inches (430 mm) at the summit of Wai’ale’ale. Here on the east side, we got over 9 inches (230 mm), and it’s again raining hard tonight.

Update: At least one person had a worse day. Jack Thompson’s house on the Big Island was flooded with several feet … of molten lava. He had the last house in the Royal Gardens subdivision.